Did you know that a recent survey showed that 98% of people in the United States eat some variation of pizza each year? 

Pizza is one of the most common foods for lunch and dinner because there are so many varieties.

If you are looking for a new type of pizza and flavor combination, there are many options to consider. 

Continue reading to discover different types of pizza toppings that you might not have tried already!

Caramelized Onions 

One of the best options to consider for different types of pizza toppings is caramelized onions.

Caramelized onions are a great addition to pizzas with goat cheese and peppers. When the onions are caramelized, they have a sweeter and less potent flavor. They still add a lot to a pizza and are easy to eat.

If you enjoy onions but don’t like the overwhelming flavor of them, this is an excellent option. Try caramelizing onions in butter until they become translucent and colored. White or Spanish onions are the best types to use for pizzas. 

BBQ Bird is one of the best pizza combinations with caramelized onions, BBQ, and gouda! 

Breakfast Ingredients 

There are many different types of pizza and some of the best ones are made with breakfast items.

Eggs, hash browns, and breakfast sausage or bacon are perfect toppings for pizza. Many people recommend using a cheese sauce or sausage gravy in place of red sauces. These flavors work well with the breakfast pizza toppings and don’t overwhelm the flavors.

You can either scramble eggs or have them cooked over medium if you want runny yolks going over the pizza. If you decide to put sausage or bacon on the pizza, it is best to cook it before adding it to the top of the pizza. You should also cook hash browns for a little bit before adding them to the top of the pizza. 

If you want to add a little sweetness to your breakfast pizza, you can top it with a little bit of syrup for added flavor! 


Squid, often called calamari, is an excellent pizza topping if you enjoy seafood. 

You can add the squid to pizza with other toppings like chorizo or other meats. Many people recommend using a garlic aioli sauce for the pizza, as it adds a lot of flavor to the squid. The red sauce can also be used, especially if it resembles a cocktail sauce, which is commonly served with calamari. 

Depending on your preferences, you can either pan-fry the squid before topping the pizza with it or fry it in beer batter. This is a fun pizza topping that can add a lot of texture and flavor to cheese pizzas. 


Common pizza topping combinations that are controversial often include pineapple in the list.

Pineapple is one of the most controversial pizza toppings because it is sweet and sour. It is often paired with ham, bacon, and red onions. Hawaiian pizzas are well-known for having pineapple on the top and use a barbeque as the sauce. 

If you enjoy sweet and spicy, this is an excellent pizza topping that will keep your tastebuds satisfied. Although canned pineapple is good on pizzas, fresh pineapple is the best way to go because it provides the most flavor. 

Peanut Butter 

Did you know that some people add peanut butter to their pepperoni pizzas?

Peanut butter is a popular ingredient for pizza because it helps sweeten spicy pizzas and adds another dimension of flavor. You can find peanut butter on Thai pizza, breakfast pizzas, and dessert pizzas. 

Asian flavors seem to be best suited for peanut butter pizza toppings. Try pairing your peanut butter with flavors like ginger, chili sauce, and sesame. If you don’t like the thick texture of peanut butter, you can lighten it up with other types of sauce that will add increased flavor. 


If you are looking for kinds of pizza toppings that are uncommon, you should consider using bananas! 

A common pizza that utilizes bananas is a curry pizza. The banana and curry complement each other and create a unique flavor that you won’t forget. This type of pizza originated from Sweden and is a staple in their country. 

Other types of pizza that might include bananas are Hawaiian pizzas and dessert pizzas. The banana pairs well with pineapple, peanut butter, and chocolate. If you are wanting a pizza with fresh fruit toppings, banana is also a great addition with berries and whipped cream. 

Butternut Squash

Autumn has arrived and it is time to embrace ingredients that are thriving this season.

If you are looking for unusual pizza toppings that fit your fall vibes, you should try adding butternut squash. Butternut squash can be cubed and cooked on top of the pizza or you can also turn it into a sauce. This flavor pairs well with bacon and chicken.

Many people recommend adding caramelized onions to a pizza with butternut squash. You should also use flavors like nutmeg, pumpkin pie spice, and cinnamon to enhance the flavors. If you add cayenne to create a little spice, you can top the pizza with maple syrup to balance the heat. 

The best part about butternut squash as a pizza topping is that it goes great with mozzarella, goat, and ricotta cheeses. 

Try These Different Types of Pizza Toppings 

If you are looking for different types of pizza toppings, there are many options to consider.

Whether you enjoy seafood, pineapple, or sweeter ingredients, you can find a place for them on your pizza. Combining flavors can create a unique combination that will leave your mouth watering and your hand reaching for more. 

Don’t be afraid to get inspiration from other countries when it comes to pizza. Curry, peanut butter, and bananas are used across the globe on pizza and are growing in popularity. 

Be sure to check out our blog for more articles about popular pizza toppings and how to turn a simple recipe into something unique!